Why this matters

Why This Matters: Real Ohio Cases

The Family Rights Movement is a national effort, and our policy work starts in Ohio. We share the cases below to honor people who were harmed or killed after documented failures in the systems that were supposed to protect them. We do not use these stories to exploit anyone's grief, and we do not claim that any single change would have guaranteed a different outcome in a particular case.

What these records do show is that the gaps are real: protection orders that were not served or not enforced, warning signs and prior reports that did not lead to lasting protection, firearms that remained in reach, danger that was not weighed before release or parenting time, children who were present for the violence, medically fragile children without specific custody safeguards, reports to children services that were not followed through, and first responders who were not set up to recognize the risk in front of them.

We have drafted solutions to help prevent this kind of tragedy from happening again. Each case is paired with the proposal that addresses that gap. Every factual claim below is tied to an official record, legislative testimony, or reporting by a major Ohio news outlet.

If you are in immediate danger, call 911.

For confidential support, the National Domestic Violence Hotline is available 24 hours a day at 1-800-799-7233, by texting START to 88788, or at thehotline.org.

If you or someone you know is thinking about suicide, call or text 988.

Aisha Fraser

Cuyahoga County, 2018

What happened.

Aisha Fraser, a Shaker Heights teacher and mother, was killed on November 17, 2018, while bringing her children for parenting time. According to the Cuyahoga County Prosecutor's Office, her former husband pleaded guilty to aggravated murder and other charges, including violating a protection order, and was sentenced to life in prison, with parole eligibility after 35 years. Their children were present. In 2015, the Supreme Court of Ohio's official disciplinary opinion records that he had pleaded guilty to attempted felonious assault and domestic violence for a 2014 attack on her, also in the presence of their children, and was sentenced to 24 months in prison.

The system gap.

A person already convicted of serious violence against the same partner was still in a position to have contact with her and their children. High-risk danger was not treated as a reason to change how bail, protection orders, and parenting time were handled. Ohio still does not require early lethality screening results to follow a family into every court that makes those decisions.

Our solution.

Aisha's Law, our strengthened redraft for reintroduction. It would require early lethality screening, same-day connection to an advocate, and that screening results reach the courts that decide bail, protection orders, and custody, so judges see the danger before those decisions are made. Aisha's Law

Related: Children and Coercive Control, which would treat a child who sees or hears the abuse as a victim. Children and Coercive Control

Ryder

Ohio. Ryder's Law is proposed, and has not yet been introduced.

What happened.

This proposal is named Ryder's Law. What those public documents do say is the gap the law is written to close. Ohio does not now have specific safeguards for medically fragile children in custody and parenting-time cases. The proposal defines a medically complex child as a child whose clinician-documented condition requires specialized feeding, medication, equipment, airway care, monitoring, or similar support, and whose interruption creates a substantial risk of serious harm. It says a medical warning should reach a decision-maker in time to matter, and that a parent should not have to buy emergency access, or start a new private case, just to get safe compliance with an existing order.

The system gap.

Under current Ohio law, a court-ordered change in physical care can proceed without a required showing that the receiving caregiver has actually demonstrated the child's specialized care, including feeding and allergy safeguards, needed supplies, and a receiving provider who will accept the child. A documented allergy or a prescribed formula can be changed without a clear, enforceable duty to follow the authorized clinical plan. After a contested transfer, there is no required independent review of the warnings, the notice, the clinical continuity, and whether the receiving care was actually ready.

Our solution.

Ryder's Law, a complete draft already shared with Ohio lawmakers. It would require a medical safety pause when a qualified clinician or a credible urgent report identifies a serious risk from a transfer, observed caregiver competency before a nonemergency move, protection against unsafe formula or treatment substitution, hospital discharge safeguards, and an independent review after a catastrophic injury or death following a contested transfer. It would also create a public way to enforce parenting orders from the first documented report. The proposal itself says these are prospective policy findings. They do not establish causation, guilt, or liability in a private dispute, and they do not promise that legislation can prevent every harm. Ryder's Law

Ryder's Law public legislative brief and complete proposal, presentation and Working Draft 2.1 texts dated November 8, 2026, prepared for consideration by the Ohio General Assembly. Read more on the Ryder's Law page

Laura Fruscella

Cuyahoga County, 2017

What happened.

Laura Fruscella, 65, of Cleveland, was found dead on October 29, 2017. According to News 5 and court records it reviewed, a domestic violence assessment had already found her at "high risk" of becoming a homicide victim. The man she had been dating was charged after an August 2017 incident, posted bond, and was released. She later reported that he had violated a protection order. A warrant was issued. News 5 reported that he was never arrested on that warrant. Cleveland 19 reported that he was later convicted of killing her. The Cuyahoga County Prosecutor's Office announced a sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole.

The system gap.

A high-risk finding and a reported protection-order violation did not keep him in custody or get the warrant served before she was killed. Ohio still treats arrest for a known protection-order violation as preferred, not required, and lethality information does not have to follow the case to the judge who sets bond.

Our solution.

Aisha's Law, so a high-risk screening result is in front of the court before bond is set. Aisha's Law

Related: our Protection Order amendments, which would require arrest for a known violation, a written explanation and supervisor review when that does not happen, and a copy for the survivor. Protection Order amendments

Our Marsy's Law amendments would also require courts to check for protection orders before setting bail. Marsy's Law amendments

A woman in Wellington

Lorain County, 2020

What happened.

On November 10, 2020, a woman was shot at her workplace in Wellington by her estranged husband, who then killed himself. She survived and was hospitalized. Wellington's police chief told News 5, "I believe we let her down," and "the system failed." According to the chief and court records cited in that reporting, she had sought help more than once, completed a 27-question lethality assessment that showed escalating danger, and the man had been charged with domestic violence, then released from jail on a personal bond with an ankle monitor. The chief said he was not wearing that monitor at the time of the shooting.

The system gap.

A documented high-risk assessment and pending domestic violence charges were not enough to keep her safe. Bond was set in a way that, according to the police chief, left her unprotected. This is the kind of case Aisha's Law was already written to address, and it still had not become law.

Our solution.

Aisha's Law, so lethality screening results reach the court that decides release, and high-risk victims are connected to an advocate the same day. Aisha's Law

Related: our Marsy's Law amendments, which would require a protection-order check before bail is set. Marsy's Law amendments

Milenna Lopez

Lorain County, 2022

What happened.

Milenna Lopez, 24, a mother of four, was killed on January 6, 2022, in Sheffield Village. Cleveland 19, citing court records from Lorain Municipal Court and Lorain County Common Pleas, reported that she had filed at least nine protection orders against her former partner since 2018, that there were multiple domestic violence cases and protection-order violation cases, and that many earlier charges were dismissed. The most recent order it identified was signed on October 18, 2021, about two and a half months before she was killed. In January 2024, the Morning Journal reported that he pleaded guilty to aggravated murder and other felonies, including violation of a protection order, and was sentenced to life in prison, with parole eligibility after 31 years.

The system gap.

A long paper trail of protection orders and alleged violations did not result in consistent enforcement. When charges are dismissed or a first violation is treated as a minor event, an order can exist on paper and still fail to protect the person who sought it.

Our solution.

Our Protection Order amendments. They would set clear service and enforcement duties, require arrest for a known violation, and create a simple way for a survivor to get a hearing when those duties are missed. Protection Order amendments

Kaitlyn Carroll Peak

Richland County, 2017

What happened.

Kaitlyn Carroll Peak, 22, of Mansfield, was killed on March 8, 2017. A News 5 investigation, based on police reports, 911 recordings, and court records, found a long history of calls for help and threats. In May 2015, after reporting an assault, she filed for a protection order. News 5 reported that Richland County deputies made four attempts to serve the other party, then stopped trying five days before the hearing, and that the case was dismissed after she did not appear. The person News 5 identified as the suspect died the following day, so there was no criminal trial for her death.

The system gap.

An order that is never fully served is hard to enforce, and the process can end if a frightened petitioner does not come back to court. News 5 also documented a pattern of reduced charges and probation after earlier incidents. There was no firm duty, deadline, or consequence when service stopped.

Our solution.

Our Protection Order amendments. They would require clear service timelines, proof of each step, and a free way for a survivor to get the process back on track if service or a hearing is missed. Protection Order amendments

Donna R. Brown

Montgomery County, 2019

What happened.

Donna R. Brown, 45, of Dayton, was killed on July 21, 2019, outside a Family Dollar store. Dayton 24/7 Now, citing court documents and Dayton police, reported that she had filed a protection order two days earlier after writing that the man had threatened to kill her and had tried to run her off the road, and that police said he had been served with the order. Police said he shot her and then himself.

The system gap.

A served protection order did not keep a firearm out of his hands. Ohio law warns people about federal gun rules, but it does not require them to surrender firearms after a protection order or to prove that they did. There is no reliable way to confirm that the weapons are gone.

Our solution.

Our Protection Order amendments. After a full hearing and a credible-threat finding, firearms would have to be surrendered within 24 hours, with proof filed within 48 hours, and the court would have to act the next business day if that proof is missing. Protection Order amendments

Emily Young

Wayne and Medina Counties, 2016

What happened.

Emily Young, 24, was killed on January 7, 2016, in Orrville. Cleveland 19 and News 5, citing police and court records, reported that she was in a vehicle with her young children when her estranged husband shot her, and that police said he later confessed and was charged with murder, domestic violence, and violating a protection order. Court records described in that reporting show that in October 2015 she obtained a domestic violence protection order that barred him from coming near her or the children and from possessing a deadly weapon. She later told the court he had violated the order by contacting her and posting false accusations online. A later sentencing article we located was behind a paywall, so this page does not state a final sentence.

The system gap.

The children were present for the violence, but Ohio still does not treat a child who sees or hears domestic violence as a victim in their own right. A protection order that barred weapons and contact was, according to her attorney's filing, already being ignored. Information about that order and her prior reports did not reliably follow him into other courts, including a later bond decision in a different county.

Our solution.

Children and Coercive Control. It would make domestic violence in the presence of a child a separate offense, treat the child as a victim with rights and support, and let survivors seek protection for a pattern of control, not only after a new injury. Children and Coercive Control

Related: our Protection Order amendments on firearm surrender and enforcement, and Aisha's Law so danger information follows the family from county to county. Protection Order amendments; Aisha's Law

Deborah Saenz

Franklin County, 2019

What happened.

Deborah Saenz, 32, of Columbus, was killed on July 12, 2019. A Columbus City Council ordinance settling a lawsuit brought by her estate states that officers responded to her apartment on a domestic violence call the day before and did not make an arrest, that a later 911 hang-up call from her number was not put out over the police radio, and that the next morning Marcos Solis III shot and killed her. An Eye on Ohio investigation, based on 911 recordings and body-camera video, reported that she had told a dispatcher he was beating her and had a gun in his hand, and that officers left without completing a lethality screen or connecting her to an advocate. NBC4 later reported, citing court records, that he pleaded guilty to involuntary manslaughter and a firearms offense. The original murder charge was dropped.

The system gap.

A traumatized person can change her story or appear "hysterical" when officers arrive. If responders are not trained to recognize that pattern, to separate the parties, and to look for the gun she already reported, they can leave a high-risk situation untouched. Ohio does not require recurring domestic violence, strangulation, or trauma-informed training for serving officers, and it does not require domestic violence training for judges or prosecutors.

Our solution.

Our Training Gaps proposal, so police, dispatchers, judges, and prosecutors get required training on lethality, trauma, coercive control, and primary-aggressor investigation. Training Gaps

Related: Aisha's Law, which would require a validated lethality screen and a same-day handoff to an advocate. Aisha's Law

Mariah Hurt

Franklin County, 2020

What happened.

Mariah Hurt, 25, a healthcare worker and mother of two, called Columbus police on the night of December 28, 2020, to report that her boyfriend had attacked her. ABC 6, which reviewed the police report, said she told officers he had punched her, shoved her through a glass door, and taken her keys, and that officers noted her cuts and then referred her to the prosecutor's office to press charges and left the scene. About seven hours later, police said, she and a friend, Wanda Myricks, 43, were stabbed to death in the same apartment building, and the boyfriend then tried to kill himself. ABC 6 reported that he was already facing assault charges from the previous month, when she had told police he kicked her, punched her, and threatened to kill her. Columbus police said a "yes" answer to a threat to kill is automatically "high danger" on the department's lethality screen and should trigger a call to advocates, but they could not say whether that screen or call was made the night before she was killed. A later criminal conviction was not located in a source we could open, so this page relies on the police account and the contemporary reporting.

The system gap.

After a reported assault, visible injuries, and a recent threat to kill, the response was to send her to the prosecutor to press charges later, rather than to make an arrest and connect her to help that night. Ohio still treats arrest in many of these situations as preferred, not required. A person with a pending assault case and a lethality warning can remain in the community while the survivor is told, in effect, to take the next step herself.

Our solution.

Relief Without Court and Aisha's Law. Aisha's Law would require a validated lethality screen and a same-day handoff to an advocate, and would put that screening result in front of the court that already had a pending assault case. Relief Without Court; Aisha's Law

Our Protection Order amendments would also require arrest for a known violation and a written explanation when officers do not arrest. Protection Order amendments

A child taken across state lines

Ohio and Virginia, 2023

What happened.

In official testimony to the Ohio House Public Safety Committee on March 11, 2026, the Ohio Domestic Violence Network described a 2023 case in which a four-year-old was taken to Virginia and not returned, despite court action and repeated efforts to get help, and was killed on October 18, 2023. ODVN read the mother's own words. She said she had talked to police, prosecutors, lawyers, and judges, felt she was not heard, was "forced to co-parent with my abuser," and believed her child's death was preventable. ODVN said that before her own death, the mother asked that this story continue to be told so other children might be safer. We are not using the child's name here.

The system gap.

When a child is taken in violation of a custody or parenting order, a parent is often told to go back to court. Safety terms in parenting orders are usually enforced only through contempt, which is too slow when a child has been taken across state lines. Coercive control and post-separation abuse are still easy to miss because they are not clearly named in Ohio law.

Our solution.

Relief Without Court, including the proposal that safety terms in parenting orders be written so law enforcement can act on them, instead of sending a parent back to file a new motion. Relief Without Court

Related: Children and Coercive Control, and the custody safety work described on our Policy Proposals page, including suggested amendments to SB 174. Children and Coercive Control; Policy Proposals

A child in Euclid

Cuyahoga County, 2018

What happened.

On March 11, 2018, a four-year-old child in Euclid died. A Cuyahoga County jury later convicted the child's mother and the mother's boyfriend of aggravated murder and other charges. The Cuyahoga County Prosecutor's Office announced the verdicts on March 7, 2019. Cleveland 19 reported that the mother was sentenced to life in prison without parole, and the boyfriend to life with parole eligibility after 20 years. A review by the Ohio Department of Job and Family Services, reported by News 5 and Ideastream, found that over about 13 months the county children services agency received five reports of suspected abuse and failed to follow required procedures. Among the state's findings: follow-up investigations and interviews were not adequate, at least one report was not started within the required 24 hours, face-to-face contact was delayed, medical records consistent with abuse were not reviewed, and statements the child made about how the injuries happened were discounted. The child's father had raised concerns. We are not using the child's name here, because no introduced Ohio law is named after the child.

The system gap.

Repeated reports of suspected abuse, including from medical and daycare sources, did not produce a timely, complete safety response. When caseworkers are not required to have strong, recurring training on child abuse, and when a child's own statements and medical findings can be set aside without a clear reason, a protective parent can report danger and still not be able to get the child to safety.

Our solution.

Children and Coercive Control. The proposal would treat a child who lives with abuse as a victim, protect the non-offending parent who reports that abuse, require written safety findings before custody decisions, and require training for police, judges, guardians ad litem, and caseworkers. Children and Coercive Control

Related custody-safety work is also described on our Policy Proposals page. Policy Proposals

The pattern

What Ohio's own numbers show

These cases are not isolated. The Ohio Domestic Violence Network reported that from July 1, 2024, to June 30, 2025, Ohio had 157 intimate partner fatalities in 108 cases, the most in ten years of counting. In 69% of cases, victims had been involved with the criminal or civil justice systems, including divorce or custody cases. In 55% of cases, the perpetrator had prior criminal justice contact. Forty cases were murder-suicides, and a sheriff's deputy was killed responding to a call.

A News 5 review of temporary protection orders in Cleveland and Cuyahoga County found that many emergency orders were never served, which left people without a full, enforceable order.

Hope

There is a way forward

The Family Rights Movement has drafted practical fixes for these gaps, written against the official text of Ohio law, so lawmakers can see exactly what would change. The proposals are collected on our Policy Proposals page. They include Aisha's Law, Ryder's Law for medically fragile children in custody cases, protection orders that can actually be served and enforced, recognition of children who live with abuse and of coercive control, stronger victims' rights under Marsy's Law, better training, and tools that give survivors relief without being told only to "go back to court."

If you want to see what a survivor can do today, visit Tools for Parents. The Survivor Helper can help a person organize a timeline, prepare a protection-order petition or a police report, apply for victims' compensation, or write a short, respectful message to a state lawmaker. Nothing is sent, filed, or posted without that person's approval. It is not a lawyer and does not replace advocates or legal aid.

If you serve in government, run a shelter, work in legal aid, or support survivors in another way, we welcome collaboration. These solutions were built to be used.

If you are in immediate danger, call 911. For confidential support, call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233, text START to 88788, or visit thehotline.org.

Last reviewed: November 10, 2026. Nothing on this draft has been published.

Add your voice

Download the Survivor Helper bot to submit your support for these reforms

You can add your voice in a few minutes, at your own pace. You review everything, and nothing is sent unless you choose to send it.

Step 1. Download the Grok Bot app (the helper runs inside it)

Sign in with an email that only you can access. The app offers in-app purchases, so check its current plan and any charges before agreeing to pay.

Step 2. Open the helper link on the same phone or tablet

Survivor Help Now by Carey

The page should say "Survivor Help Now" and "by Carey." Follow the app's steps to add it. If you see a different helper, stop and do not share anything personal.

Step 3. Tell it what you want to support

For example: I want to support the Family Rights Movement's work to close the gaps these cases show. Help me ask my state representative to support them.

Step 4. Review the draft it prepares

The helper prepares a short, respectful support message for you to read. You can find your own state representative at USAGov's elected officials finder. Change anything you like. You do not have to share your story or any private details.

Step 5. You decide and send it yourself

Nothing is sent, posted, or submitted without your approval. You can stop at any time.

If you are in immediate danger, call 911. For confidential support, the National Domestic Violence Hotline is available at thehotline.org.